Home / After the job

How to Vet Roofers in Boise

A roofer can be friendly, quick to call back and still be the wrong hire. Vetting is the boring part, and it is the part that protects your money. Here is the order to do it in.

Start with the state record, not the truck wrap

Idaho runs a contractor registration program for people who do construction work for hire, including roofing. The state licensing agency (currently the Idaho Division of Occupational and Professional Licenses) publishes a public lookup where you can search a business or person by name or registration number. That search is the first thing to do with any roofer you are considering, and it takes about two minutes.

Do it yourself. A registration number printed on a bid or a yard sign is a claim; the record on the state site is the evidence. When you search, check three things: that the name on the record matches the name on the bid and the contract, that the registration is current rather than expired, and whether the record shows anything unusual such as a disciplinary action. Save a screenshot with the date. If the names do not match, ask why before going further. Sometimes there is an ordinary explanation, like a trade name, and sometimes there is not.

Verify current rules

Registration requirements, exemptions and what the state checks can change. Treat this page as a starting point and confirm the current rules directly with the state agency before you rely on them. Registration is also not the same thing as a skills test: it tells you the business is on file with the state, not that it does good work.

Get insurance proof from the agent, not the salesperson

Roofing is dangerous work done on your property. If a worker is injured or a neighbor's car is hit by falling debris, you want the roofer's insurance to respond, not yours. There are two coverages to ask about:

  • General liability. Covers damage the contractor causes to your property or someone else's during the job.
  • Workers' compensation. Covers the roofer's employees if they are hurt. If the company says it has no employees, ask who will be on the roof, because a crew of "subcontractors" can still leave questions about coverage.

Ask for a certificate of insurance and request that the insurance agent send it to you directly. A PDF forwarded by the salesperson can be outdated or altered. The certificate lists the agent's contact details; call that number, confirm the policy is active and will be active on your job dates, and ask whether you can be listed as a certificate holder so you are notified if coverage lapses.

DocumentWhat it provesWhat it does not prove
State registration recordThe business is registered with Idaho under that nameWorkmanship quality, current insurance on your dates
Certificate of insurancePolicies existed on the date it was issuedThat the policy is still active today: call the agent
Manufacturer credentialThe roofer has some relationship with that product makerThat your roof qualifies for an enhanced warranty
Online reviewsSome customers were happy or unhappyAnything specific about your roof or your contract

Ask how the roofer handles lien waivers

This is the question most homeowners never ask, and it is the one that can cost the most. In Idaho, as in most states, people who supply labor or materials to a construction project can file a lien against the property if they are not paid. That includes the shingle supplier and any subcontractor. If your roofer collects your money and does not pay the supplier, the supplier can look to your house.

A lien waiver is a signed document in which a contractor, sub or supplier acknowledges payment up to a certain point and gives up lien rights for that amount. The practical habit: each time you make a payment, you receive a waiver for the work covered by the previous payment, and with the final payment you receive final waivers, including from the main material supplier on larger jobs.

Idaho law also requires contractors on many residential projects to give homeowners written disclosures before the contract is signed, covering topics such as lien rights, insurance and your right to request lien waivers. Ask whether you will receive that disclosure. A roofer who does this routinely will know exactly what you mean. One who seems surprised by the question has told you something useful. As with registration, confirm current requirements with the state or a real estate attorney rather than relying on this summary.

References, addresses and a drive-by

Ask for three recent residential jobs in the Treasure Valley, ideally from the last year or two, and ask at least one to be a roof that has been through a winter. Then do something most people skip: drive past. You can see from the street whether the shingle lines run straight, whether the drip edge and gutters look tidy, and whether the ridge sits evenly.

When you call a reference, skip "were you happy?" and ask specific questions. Did the crew start when they said? Were there change orders, and were they explained before the work was done? Did the cleanup include a magnet sweep? Did anything leak afterward, and how fast did the roofer come back? Was the permit inspection completed? These answers tell you how the company behaves when something does not go to plan, which is the only time it really matters.

The vetting call, in order

Put these to every roofer on your list before you schedule an estimate. Same questions, same order, notes on paper. It turns a sales conversation into a comparison.

  1. What is your Idaho registration number and the exact business name on it?

    You will look it up yourself afterward. Write down the name they give you so you can compare it with the record and the contract.

  2. Can your insurance agent send me a certificate directly?

    A yes with the agent's name is the answer you want. Hesitation or "I'll text you a photo" is worth noting.

  3. Who will be on my roof and who supervises them?

    Your own crew, subcontractors, or a mix? Who is the site lead and can you reach that person during the job?

  4. Will I get lien waivers with each payment?

    And will you receive the residential disclosure before signing? A routine answer here is a good sign.

  5. Who pulls the permit?

    Many cities in the valley require a permit for reroofing. The contractor normally applies; the permit should be in the contractor's name, not yours.

  6. Can I see three recent local jobs?

    Addresses you can drive past, plus a phone number for at least one homeowner.

Who makes the shortlist

After the calls and lookups, you should be able to sort roofers into three groups without much agonizing.

  • the registration, insurance and references all check outschedule an estimate and move to the bid comparison
  • one document is late but the answers were straightgive a firm deadline, then decide
  • the names do not match or insurance cannot be confirmeddrop them, however good the price sounds
  • you were pressured to sign before checking anythingread the red flags guide before you reply

Two or three vetted roofers is plenty. With that shortlist, the next job is comparing their bids line by line, and later reading the contract and payment schedule. If you would rather not start the search cold, you can describe your project and ask to be matched; vet whoever you hear from with exactly the same steps.

Not a contractor

Roofers in Boise is an independent guide. We do not perform roofing work or vouch for any contractor. Always do your own checks.

Roofer matching

Ready to talk to roofers?

Describe your roof and where you live in the Treasure Valley. We read every request and reply by email about next steps.

Start a matching request